A Clontarf resident’s street library, once labelled non-compliant, has become a symbol of community spirit after widespread support helped keep it alive.
Background and Origin of the Dispute
In January 2025, Clontarf resident Melissa Forbes placed a small book-sharing box on the grass verge outside her home near the Beedham Street bus stop. The “give a book, take a book” initiative aimed to encourage reading and neighbourly connection across the Redcliffe Peninsula.
Shortly after installation, a complaint was lodged with the Moreton Bay City Council. The structure was deemed non-compliant as it stood on council land in line with a bus shelter and footpath, which raised safety and access concerns. Forbes was informed that continuing the project would require a permit and $20 million in public liability insurance.
Although she submitted the required application, the permit was later denied.
Community Reaction and Support
The decision prompted strong community response. Residents across Clontarf and Redcliffe rallied behind Forbes, writing letters and launching an online petition that gathered hundreds of signatures within days.
Locals expressed that the book nook had quickly become a valued part of the neighbourhood, encouraging connection and small acts of generosity. Support also arrived from further afield, with messages of encouragement sent from overseas, including the UK, the US, and Serbia.
The public interest even drew a visit from a local representative, who agreed the structure posed no harm. The groundswell of backing underscored how small community efforts can unite residents around shared values.
Resolution and New Beginning
Seven months after the initial complaint, Forbes relocated the street library from the verge to her fence line to comply with council safety requirements. The revised setup no longer required a permit and was welcomed as a compliant solution.
The book box returned under a new name — the “Illegal Book Box” — referencing the earlier dispute. Despite the setback, Forbes said the experience helped her achieve the community engagement she had originally hoped for.
Council later confirmed it was satisfied with the revised location and acknowledged that such small libraries can be valuable local assets when safely installed.
Lasting Impact in Clontarf
Since its reinstatement, the “Illegal Book Box” has continued to operate in Clontarf, with locals contributing and borrowing books regularly. Forbes has since supported efforts to provide clear information for residents interested in setting up their own street libraries to avoid similar obstacles.
Forbes reflected that the experience prompted broader discussion about how neighbourhoods can balance community projects with public safety rules.
Published 6-Nov-2025
